Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review

✅ 全文

豆科植物-根瘤菌相互作用的温度敏感性:根系形态建成与变异性:综述

作者 M Panchulakshmi; Dheebakaran Ga; N.K. Sathyamoorthy; D. Jegadeeswari; B. Arthirani; M. Dhasarathan; S. Sanjeev Kumar 期刊 Legume Research - An International Journal 发表日期 2026 ISSN 0250-5371 DOI 10.18805/lr-5609 类型 原创研究 (Original Research)

📄 英文摘要 English Abstract

EN

Legumes are vital to food and nutritional security, often referred to as the “poor man’s meat” because of their high protein content. Their role in sustainable agriculture is anchored in Biological Nitrogen Fixation (BNF), a symbiotic process involving rhizobia that is highly sensitive to fluctuation in soil temperature. Soil temperature governs root system architecture (RSA), microbial colonization and enzymatic activity and is a critical determinant of legume productivity. Extreme soil temperatures impair root activity, microbial symbiosis and nitrogen fixation. This synthesis drew from over 91 out of 124 peer-reviewed studies spanning molecular biology, microbial ecology and agronomic interventions. It examines temperature thresholds affecting nodulation kinetics, RSA traits and symbiotic gene expression, including heat shock proteins (HSPs), cold responsive genes (e.g., GmFRI-1) and hormonal signalling pathways. RSA traits such as root elongation, branching, biomass and vascular development are temperature sensitive, with optimal performance between 20-30oC. Cold stress delays nodulation and reduces nitrogenase activity (~60% at 4oC), while heat stress damages root tip and reduces nitrogenase reductase (~42%). Molecular responses include disrupted auxin transport and HSP induction. Thermotolerant rhizobial strains, Nod factors and inoculation strategies support symbiosis. Agronomic practices such as mulching, conservation tillage and strategic sowing buffer soil thermal regimes and enhance microbial activity. Managing the thermal sensitivity of the legume-rhizobium system through integrated genetic, microbial and agronomic strategies are vital for climate resilient legume cultivation and sustained productivity under variable soil temperature regimes.

📄 中文摘要 Chinese Abstract

中文
豆类对粮食和营养安全至关重要,因其高蛋白含量常被称为"穷人的肉类"。其在可持续农业中的作用根源于生物固氮(BNF),这是一个涉及根瘤菌的共生过程,对土壤温度波动高度敏感。土壤温度决定根系构型(RSA)、微生物定殖和酶活性,是豆类生产力的关键决定因素。极端土壤温度会损害根系活性、微生物共生和氮固定。豆类在粮食和营养安全中发挥着关键作用,尤其在低收入和素食人群中,因其蛋白质、必需氨基酸和可负担性而获得"穷人的肉类"之称。富含铁、锌和叶酸等微量营养素,有助于均衡饮食并对抗隐性饥饿。从农学角度看,豆类通过生物固氮(BNF)维持农业系统,共生根瘤菌将大气中的氮转化为植物可利用的形式,减少化肥依赖并提高土壤肥力(Wissal等,2020;Owaresat等,2023)。

📋 英文结构化总结 English Structured Summary

全文整理

EN

Header:

Background Legumes are vital to food and nutritional security, often referred to as the “poor man’s meat” because of their high protein content. Their role in sustainable agriculture is anchored in Biological Nitrogen Fixation (BNF), a symbiotic process involving rhizobia that is highly sensitive to fluctuation in soil temperature. Soil temperature governs root system architecture (RSA), microbial colonization and enzymatic activity and is a critical determinant of legume productivity. Extreme soil temperatures impair root activity, microbial symbiosis and nitrogen fixation. Legumes play a pivotal role in food and nutritional security, especially in low-income and vegetarian populations, earning the moniker “poor man’s meat” due to their protein, essential amino acids and affordability. Rich in micronutrients like iron, zinc and folate, contribute to balanced diets and combat hidden hunger. Agronomically, legumes sustain farming systems through biological nitrogen fixation (BNF), wherein symbiotic rhizobia convert atmospheric nitrogen into plant-available forms, reducing fertilizer dependency and enhancing soil fertility (Wissal et al., 2020; Owaresat et al., 2023).

Header:

Methods This synthesis drew from over 91 out of 124 peer-reviewed studies spanning molecular biology, microbial ecology and agronomic interventions. From an initial 162 publications retrieved via Scopus, Web of Science, Google Scholar, PubMed and CAB Abstracts using targeted keywords, 124 were shortlisted after screening and 91 peer-reviewed studies were retained for final synthesis, based on rigor and relevance. Thematic organization focused on temperature thresholds influencing nodulation.

Header:

Results It examines temperature thresholds affecting nodulation kinetics, RSA traits and symbiotic gene expression, including heat shock proteins (HSPs), cold responsive genes (e.g., GmFRI-1) and hormonal signalling pathways. RSA traits such as root elongation, branching, biomass and vascular development are temperature sensitive, with optimal performance between 20-30°C. Cold stress delays nodulation and reduces nitrogenase activity (~60% at 4°C), while heat stress damages root tip and reduces nitrogenase reductase (~42%). Molecular responses include disrupted auxin transport and HSP induction. Thermotolerant rhizobial strains, Nod factors and inoculation strategies support symbiosis.

Header:

Data Summary Cold stress reduces nitrogenase activity (~60% at 4°C), while heat stress reduces nitrogenase reductase (~42%). Optimal performance for RSA traits occurs between 20-30°C. The review retained 91 peer-reviewed studies from an initial 162 publications.

Header:

Conclusions Managing the thermal sensitivity of the legume-rhizobium system through integrated genetic, microbial and agronomic strategies are vital for climate resilient legume cultivation and sustained productivity under variable soil temperature regimes.

Header:

Practical Significance Agronomic practices such as mulching, conservation tillage and strategic sowing buffer soil thermal regimes and enhance microbial activity.

📋 中文结构化总结 Chinese Structured Summary

中文

背景:

豆类对粮食和营养安全至关重要,因其高蛋白含量常被称为"穷人的肉类"。其在可持续农业中的作用根源于生物固氮(BNF),这是一个涉及根瘤菌的共生过程,对土壤温度波动高度敏感。土壤温度决定根系构型(RSA)、微生物定殖和酶活性,是豆类生产力的关键决定因素。极端土壤温度会损害根系活性、微生物共生和氮固定。豆类在粮食和营养安全中发挥着关键作用,尤其在低收入和素食人群中,因其蛋白质、必需氨基酸和可负担性而获得"穷人的肉类"之称。富含铁、锌和叶酸等微量营养素,有助于均衡饮食并对抗隐性饥饿。从农学角度看,豆类通过生物固氮(BNF)维持农业系统,共生根瘤菌将大气中的氮转化为植物可利用的形式,减少化肥依赖并提高土壤肥力(Wissal等,2020;Owaresat等,2023)。

方法:

本综述综合了91项(共124项)同行评审研究,涵盖分子生物学、微生物生态学和农学干预领域。通过Scopus、Web of Science、Google Scholar、PubMed和CAB Abstracts使用目标关键词初步检索到162篇文献,经筛选后入围124篇,最终基于严谨性和相关性保留了91篇同行评审研究进行综合。主题组织聚焦于影响结瘤的温度阈值。

结果:

本研究探讨了影响结瘤动力学、根系构型性状和共生基因表达的温度阈值,包括热激蛋白(HSPs)、冷响应基因(如GmFRI-1)和激素信号通路。根系构型性状如根系伸长、分枝、生物量和维管发育对温度敏感,在20-30°C之间表现最佳。冷胁迫延迟结瘤并降低固氮酶活性(4°C时约降低60%),而热胁迫损害根尖并降低固氮酶还原酶(约降低42%)。分子响应包括生长素运输紊乱和热激蛋白诱导。耐热的根瘤菌菌株、结瘤因子和接种策略有助于维持共生关系。

数据摘要:

冷胁迫降低固氮酶活性(4°C时约降低60%),而热胁迫降低固氮酶还原酶(约降低42%)。根系构型性状的最佳表现温度范围为20-30°C。本综述从初始162篇文献中保留了91篇同行评审研究。

结论:

通过整合遗传、微生物和农学策略来管理豆类-根瘤菌系统的热敏感性,对于气候适应性豆类栽培和在可变土壤温度条件下维持生产力至关重要。

实践意义:

覆盖、保护性耕作和战略性播种等农学措施可调节土壤热环境并增强微生物活性。

📖 英文全文 English Full Text

EN

LR-5609 [1-10] REVIEW ARTICLE Legume Research- An International Journal

Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review M Panchulakshmi1, Dheebakaran Ga1, N.K. Sathyamoorthy1, D. Jegadeeswari2, B. Arthirani3, M. Dhasarathan1, S. Mohan Kumar1

10.18805/LR-5609

ABSTRACT Legumes are vital to food and nutritional security, often referred to as the “poor man’s meat” because of their high protein content. Their role in sustainable agriculture is anchored in Biological Nitrogen Fixation (BNF), a symbiotic process involving rhizobia that is highly sensitive to fluctuation in soil temperature. Soil temperature governs root system architecture (RSA), microbial colonization and enzymatic activity and is a critical determinant of legume productivity. Extreme soil temperatures impair root activity, microbial symbiosis and nitrogen fixation. This synthesis drew from over 91 out of 124 peer-reviewed studies spanning molecular biology, microbial ecology and agronomic interventions. It examines temperature thresholds affecting nodulation kinetics, RSA traits and symbiotic gene expression, including heat shock proteins (HSPs), cold responsive genes (e.g., GmFRI-1) and hormonal signalling pathways. RSA traits such as root elongation, branching, biomass and vascular development are temperature sensitive, with optimal performance between 20-30 C. Cold stress delays nodulation and reduces nitrogenase activity (~60% at 4 C), while heat stress damages root tip and reduces nitrogenase reductase (~42%). Molecular responses include disrupted auxin transport and HSP induction. Thermotolerant rhizobial strains, Nod factors and inoculation strategies support symbiosis. Agronomic practices such as mulching, conservation tillage and strategic sowing buffer soil thermal regimes and enhance microbial activity. Managing the thermal sensitivity of the legume-rhizobium system through integrated genetic, microbial and agronomic strategies are vital for climate resilient legume cultivation and sustained productivity under variable soil temperature regimes. Key words: Legume crops, Management, Rhizobium, Root nodules, Soil temperature, Symbiosis.

Legumes play a pivotal role in food and nutritional security, especially in low-income and vegetarian populations, earning the moniker “poor man’s meat” due to their protein, essential amino acids and affordability. Rich in micronutrients like iron, zinc and folate, contribute to balanced diets and combat hidden hunger. Agronomically, legumes sustain farming systems through biological nitrogen fixation (BNF), wherein symbiotic rhizobia convert atmospheric nitrogen into plant-available forms, reducing fertilizer dependency and enhancing soil fertility (W issal et al., 2020; Owaresat et al., 2023). Their dual roles in nutrition and agro-ecological resilience makes legumes central to climate-smart agriculture and inclusive food systems.

Global and regional legume crops in food security Legumes have diverse global centres of origin, reflecting their ancient domestication across continents. Chickpea and Lentil were domesticated in the Fertile Crescent (Zohary et al., 2012). Peas traces its roots to the Mediterranean Basin and Central Asia. Soybean originated in northeastern China (Hymowitz and Shurtleff, 2005). The common bean has dual centres in Mesoamerica and the Andean region of South America (Bellucci et al., 2013), while Faba bean originated in the Near East, although its wild progenitor remains unidentified (Caracuta et al., 2016). Groundnut is native to South America, particularly Brazil and Peru (Krapovickas, 2017). Cowpea emerged from Sub-Saharan

Agro Climate Research Centre, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Coimbatore-641 003, Tamil Nadu, India. 2 Soil Science and Agricultural Chemistry, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Coimbatore-641 003, Tamil Nadu, India. 3 Agricultural Research Station, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Kovilpatti-628 501, Tamil Nadu, India. Corresponding Author: Dheebakaran Ga, Agro Climate Research Centre, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Coimbatore641 003, Tamil Nadu, India. Email: gadheebakaran@tnau.ac.in ORCIDs: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-6227-3720, https://orcid.org/ 0000-0002-0603-192X, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7296-4808, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2806-8280, https://orcid.org/00000002-1651-3922, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9192-4430, https:/ /orcid.org/0000-0002-2301-438X How to cite this article: Panchulakshmi, M., Ga., D., Sathyamoorthy, N.K, Jegadeeswari, D., Arthirani, B., Dhasarathan, M. and Kumar, S.M. (2026). Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review. Legume Research. 1-10. doi: 10.18805/LR-5609. Submitted: 24-11-2025

Africa, adapted to arid climates and low-input systems (Boukar et al., 2019). Grass pea, known for its drought tolerance, is native to the Mediterranean and South Asia (Gonçalves et al., 2024). India is a major centre of origin for several tropical legumes such as pigeon pea, black gram, green

1

Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review gram, Horse Gram, Lablab Bean and Moth Bean are native to the Indian subcontinent, where they have long supported rainfed subsistence farming and protein nutrition (Srivastava et al., 2025). These origins underscore the ecological and cultural significance of legumes in shaping resilient food systems across agro climatic zones in India. Leguminosae crops addresses global food and nutritional security challenges, particularly in regions with protein-deficient diets (Salaria et al., 2022; Amel et al., 2018), being rich in protein (20-35%) (Grdeñ and Jakubczyk, 2023), essential amino acids, fibre, vitamins and minerals (Çakir et al., 2019). Legumes offer a nutritionally balanced alternative to animal protein (Rajput et al., 2024), make them especially valuable in vegetarian populations in India, where pulses are dietary stables. Globally, rising demand for plant-based proteins reflects health and sustainability concerns (Aschemann-Witzel et al., 2021). Legumes like lentils, chickpeas, mung beans and soybeans are recognized as “future-smart foods” for their nutritional and ecological resilience (Sharma et al., 2024). In India, pulses contribute significantly to protein intake and are culturally embedded in rural traditional food systems (Singh et al., 2017; Sonika et al., 2020). Beyond human nutrition, legumes also support sustainable diets by reducing reliance on resource-intensive animal agriculture (Röös et al., 2020). Their inclusion in cropping systems enhances food system diversity and resilience, align with the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly SDG 2 (Zero Hunger) and SDG 13 (Climate Action) (Unicef, 2022). Despite their benefits, legume production is constrained by low yields, biotic and abiotic stresses and limited policy support. Breeding, biofortification and value addition are key to enhancing their role in global food and nutritional security worldwide.

Soil temperature and crop production Soil temperature is a fundamental environmental variable regulating biological, chemical and physical processes in agriculture. It directly influences seed germination, root development, microbial activity, nutrient mineralization and water uptake, making it a critical determinant of crop productivity (Hatfield and Prueger, 2015). Optimal soil temperatures for tropical and subtropical crops are typically 20-30C, varying by species and growth stage. Deviations from this range due to seasonal or climate induced shifts can disrupt enzymatic activity and hormonal signalling, impairing seed imbibition, radicle emergence and root

Fig 1: System of literature review process adopted in this review article.

Objective and scope of the review This review synthesizes current knowledge on soil temperature effects on legume rhizobium interactions, with emphasis on root morphogenesis and nitrogen dynamics across physiological, molecular, microbial and agronomic dimensions relevant to climate resilient cultivation. The process is illustrated in the graphical abstract (Fig 1) and PRISMA flow diagram (Fig 2). From an initial 162 publications retrieved via Scopus, W eb of Science, Google Scholar, PubMed and CAB Abstracts using targeted keywords, 124 were shortlisted after screening and 91 peer-reviewed studies were retained for final synthesis, based on rigor and relevance. Thematic organization focused on temperature thresholds influencing nodulation, root system architecture (RSA) and symbiotic gene expression. Key regulators included heat shock proteins, cold responsive genes (e.g., GmFRI-1) and hormonal pathways modulating auxin-cytokinin dynamics. Integrated analysis covered physiological traits (root elongation, branching, biomass), microbial adaptations (strain tolerance, inoculant formulations) and agronomic practices (mulching, conservation tillage, co-inoculation) that shape symbiotic efficiency under variable soil temperatures. 2

Fig 2: PRISMA flow diagram. Legume Research- An International Journal

Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review elongation. (Yanjun et al., 2005). Cold soils delay germination and weaken seedling vigour, while excessive warmth accelerates metabolism but impairs root integrity and water balance. Nutrient solubility and uptake is also affected, with phosphorus availability reduced in cooler soils due to limited microbial activity (Blackwell et al., 2010). Microbial processes like decomposition, nitrification and symbiosis are highly temperature sensitive, shaping microbial biomass, diversity and nutrient cycling. Conservation practices such as mulching, cover cropping and residue management help maintain optimal thermal regimes for microbial health and crop resilience (Lal, 2020). Moreover, soil temperature interacts with moisture dynamics, influencing evapotranspiration, root water uptake and drought tolerance. Recent studies highlight its role in regulating enzymatic activity, membrane fluidity and hormonal signalling, affecting germination, root growth and biomass accumulation (Yeremko et al., 2025). Understanding soil temperature dynamics is crucial for optimizing legume productivity, guiding sowing windows, varietal choice and inoculant strategies for climate resilient agriculture. W hile warmer soils may extend temperate growing seasons but also intensify heat stress and disrupt root–microbe interactions in tropical zones. A nuanced grasp of these dynamics is essential for designing adaptive agronomic practices, selecting thermotolerant cultivars and refining sowing schedules under variable climates.

Root system architecture under soil temperature stress The rhizosphere is highly sensitive to temperature fluctuations, especially in legumes where root-microbe interactions drive productivity. Soil temperature shapes root system architecture (RSA), influencing elongation, branching and biomass (Luo et al., 2020). RSA governs water and nutrient uptake, microbial colonization and stress resilience. A dual fertilizing layer at the 30/ cm crest buffers soil temperature, enhancing root geometry through shallower angles, lateral proliferation, increased diameter and vertical expansion (Kang et al., 2025). Conversely, cooler root zones (7-13C) restrict root growth and reduce vascular duct size, impairing mineral uptake and translocation (Miao et al., 2023). Root elongation Highly temperature sensitive, elongation in soybean peaks near 30 C, while drops by 70% at 12 C (de Moraes and Gusmao, 2021). Near-zero temperatures halted root extension in cereals like wheat and maize (Morandage et al., 2021), while cooler soils reduce root length density in spring cereals, limiting soil exploration (Qin et al., 2018). Most legumes elongate optimally 20-28 C; below 15 C, cell division slows, while above 35 C root tips are damaged, reducing elongation and lateral root formation. Lateral root formation Moderate soil warmth promoting auxin-mediated lateral root development, while excessive heat disrupts hormonal Volume Issue

signalling, producing sparse roots. Tripathi et al. (2024) reported that legumes exposed to fluctuating soil temperatures exhibited altered branching patterns and reduced adventitious root density, impairing nodulation and nitrogen fixation. Biomass accumulation Root biomass peaks under optimal soil temperature and moisture. Legumes showed higher root biomass cooler temperatures (19-20 C), due to improved water retention and reduced thermal stress (Tchapga et al., 2023). Elevated temperatures accelerate decomposition but reduce biomass via increased respiration and lower carbon allocation. In maize, root dry weight was highest under 30/ 22 C and 35/27C regimes (Walne and Reddy, 2022), while warming 4-6C above ambient deteriorated fine roots and reduce absorptive root biomass (Parts et al., 2019). In cold ecosystems, warming increased root, fungal and fungivore biomass, though bacterial and archaeal levels remained stable (Salazar et al., 2020).

Thermal sensitivity of rhizobial function Rhizobial activity and colonization under soil temperature stress Soil temperature is a critical determinant of rhizobial activity, colonization efficiency and legume-rhizobium symbiosis. Rhizobia exhibit optimal metabolic activity and BNF between 20-30 C (Bordeleau and Prévost, 1994), while below 15 C or above 35 C impair bacterial viability, signal exchange and symbiotic function. Low temperatures slow rhizobial metabolism, reduce Nod factor synthesis and delay colonization (Liu et al., 2019). Cold stress also alters gene expression in rhizobia and host roots, affecting early signalling and nodule initiation. In contrast, elevated temperatures may boost root growth but disrupt rhizobial membrane integrity, enzymatic stability and signalling molecule production (Kumar et al., 2023; Caruso et al., 2014). Soil temperature strongly influences rhizobial motility, chemotaxis and attachment to root hairs, critical steps for colonization. Moderate warmth enhances these processes and boosts nodule biomass, while temperatures outside the optimal (20-30 C) delay colonization (Zhang et al., 2020). Optimal temperatures (20-30 C) favour rhizobial colonization, nodule development and nitrogenase efficiency. Conversely, temperatures below 15 C or above 30 C can hinder nodulation and reduce nitrogen fixation rates (Aranjuelo et al., 2007; Mohammadi et al., 2012). Importantly, rhizobial strains vary in thermal tolerance, with some maintaining symbiotic efficiency under heat stress, making their selection vital for legume cultivation in warming climates (Asadi Rahmani et al., 2009; Alexandre and Oliveira, 2011). Rhizobial inoculant formulation and delivery systems The efficacy of rhizobial inoculants under temperature stress depends on both strain selection and formulation. Carrier-based inoculants using peat, lignite, or charcoal help buffer rhizobia against desiccation and thermal 3

Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review fluctuations, extending shelf life and field viability (Bashan et al., 2014). Liquid inoculants enriched with protective polymers and osmolytes enhance thermal tolerance and rapid colonization, especially in high-temperature environments (Tittabutr et al., 2007). Encapsulation in alginate beads or biochar matrices creates protective microenvironments that moderate temperature and moisture stress (Schoebitz and López Belchí, 2016). Precision placement of inoculants near the rhizosphere, particularly in mulched or conservation tillage systems, enhances nodulation. Combining thermotolerant strains with optimized formulations and targeted delivery sustains symbiosis under climate variability. Molecular mechanisms of nodule initiation Nodule formation begins with molecular dialogue between host roots and compatible rhizobia. W ithin nodules, rhizobia differentiate into nitrogen-fixing Bacteroides (Ledermann et al., 2021), supported by spatially and temporally regulated signalling networks. Nodules create a microaerobic niche for nutrient exchange and nitrogenase activity. Soil temperature influences nodule development and rhizobial strain competitiveness, for instance, B. diazoefficiens USDA 110/122 perform best at 28/23C, while B. japonicum USDA 123 prefers cooler conditions (Shiro et al., 2016). Maintaining optimal soil temperatures and using thermotolerant strains with suitable soil management enhances symbiotic efficiency and legume productivity.

Thermal sensitivity of rhizobial function Soil temperature on nodule formation Rhizobia form a symbiotic association with legumes, enabling atmospheric nitrogen fixation through nodule formation (Masson-Boivin and Sachs, 2018; Raza et al., 2020). The process begins with root-exuded flavonoids that attract compatible rhizobia and induce Nod factor synthesis (AbdAlla et al., 2023). These signals recognized by root surface receptors, triggering root hair curling and infection thread formation (Krönauer and Radutoiu, 2021; Ghantasala and Roy Choudhury, 2022). Soil temperature critically influences rhizobial strain competitiveness and nodule occupancy. For example, B. diazoefficiens USDA 110/122 nodulated optimally at 28/23C, while B. japonicum USDA 123 prefers cooler conditions, highlighting the importance of temperature-specific strain selection (Shiro et al., 2016). Temperature effects on nodule development Optimal root-zone temperatures for nodule development are species-specific: 25C for tropical beans, 20C for peas and 15C for lentils (Junior et al., 2005). Deviations delay nodule initiation and reduce size, number and growth rate. Rhizobial colonization also varies with temperature, rhizosphere populations rise between 20-30 C, while endophytic movement in chickpea peaks at 25 C (Landa et al., 2004). Co-inoculation with Bradyrhizobium and Azospirillum brasilense enhances nodulation in soybean under 20-30 C, with peak efficiency at 76% soil water retention and 112 nodules per plant (Deak et al., 2019). 4

In contrast, low temperatures (15C) reduce clover productivity and delay nodulation (Janczarek et al., 2024), while high temperatures (>40 C) can cause nodulation failure and genetic stress in rhizobia (Hungria and Vargas, 2000). Role of heat shock proteins in nodule development In legumes, Heat shock proteins (HSPs) are essential for symbiosis during nodule development, preventing protein aggregation and maintaining cellular homeostasis (Ogden et al., 2017; Flynn et al., 2024). Small HSPs like GmHSP17.9 inhibit thermal aggregation of malate dehydrogenase at 45 C and support early signalling and differentiation (Yang et al., 2022). HSPs also safeguard nitrogenase enzymes from heat-induced denaturation and oxidative stress, preserving nitrogen fixation (Rajaram and Apte, 2008). Heat-tolerant rhizobial strains such as CIAT899 upregulate specific HSPs (e.g., 21/ kDa) under 40-45C, enhancing thermotolerance (Michiels et al., 1994). Their stress-induced expression makes HSPs valuable biomarkers and breeding targets for heat-resilient legumes, supporting symbiotic efficiency under climate stress (Aranjuelo et al., 2015).

Cold responsive genes and their impact on nodulation Cold responsive genes enable legumes to sustain symbiosis under low-temperature stress by encoding proteins such as C-repeat binding factors (CBFs), antifreeze proteins and Osmo protectant enzymes that preserve cellular homeostasis (Thomashow, 2010). Active rhizobial symbiosis enhances cold tolerance in alfalfa by boosting antioxidant defences and modulating cold-response genes (Liu et al., 2019). Cold stress disrupts hormonal signalling, cytokinin is pivotal for Nod factor transduction and nodule organogenesis (Dolgikh et al., 2016), while low temperatures suppress auxin transporters (PIN1-PIN7), impairing root elongation and gravitropism (Tiwari et al., 2023). Nitrogenase activity is highly cold-sensitive, declining by 60% in Bradyrhizobium japonicum nodules within 24 hours at 4 C (Zhang et al., 2014). However, genes like GmFRI-1 help maintain nodulation under cold stress, its overexpression enhances soyabean nodule formation at 4 C, while RNAi silencing inhibits it (Zhang et al., 2025).

Nodule senescence under temperature stress Root nodule senescence is an orchestrated process involving the programmed death of bacteroids and plant cells, which results in a gradual decline in nitrogen fixation (Tsyganova et al., 2023). Temperature strongly shapes senescence, at 28 C, wild-type SGE nodules senesced centrally after three days, while mutant lines SGEFix”-3 and SGEFix”-7 showed rapid apex and basal senescence within one day (Serova et al., 2023a). Heat-induced senescence is also governed by hormonal pathways, with upregulation of GA deactivation (PsGA2ox1), ethylene (PsACS2, PsACO1), j asmonic acid (PsLoxN1) and ABA synthesis genes (PsNCED2, PsAO3), alongside downregulation of GA biosynthesis gene PsGA20ox1-collectively promsoting nodule aging (Serova et al., 2023b). Legume Research- An International Journal

Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review

Nitrogen fixation dynamics under soil temperature variability Biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) is highly soil temperaturesensitive with extremes threaten symbiotic efficiency and crop productivity (Flynn et al., 2024; Kajić et al., 2016). Conservation tillage enhances nodulation and BNF by improving moisture retention, moderating temperature and boosting microbial biomass (Torabian et al., 2019). Rootzone temperature (RZT) is critical, nitrogen fixation in grass pea halts below 10 C, temperate rhizobia peak at 25 C and cold-adapted strains at 15 C (Mahdavi et al., 2010). This highlights the importance of matching rhizobial thermal adaptation to local soil conditions. In Arctic soils, BNF peaks below 14C with adequate moisture, suggesting vulnerability of cold-adapted diazotrophs to warming (Rousk et al., 2018). In temperate zones, BNF rates rise with temperature, peaking at 35C under moderate moisture (Li et al., 2018). In chickpea, nitrogenase and nitrate reductase activities

peak during flowering but decline at ~39C, with nitrogenase reductase dropping by 40.12% and nitrogenase by 20.21% (Jain et al., 2014). Ammonium assimilation enzymes GS and GOGAT are even more sensitive to heat stress (Hungria and Kaschuk, 2014). These findings highlight the critical need for temperature resilient symbiotic systems to sustain BNF under climate stress. The interactions between soil temperature and key activities in legumerhizobium systems are summarized in Table 1 and a graphical abstract (Fig 3). Agronomic and microbial interventions for soil temperature management Soil temperature regulates seed germination, root development, microbial activity and nutrient cycling, making its management vital under climate variability. Mulching with straw, leaf litter, or green manures, buffers temperature, conserves moisture and promotes microbial health. In Indian natural farming, mulching synergizes with inputs

Table 1: Optimal soil temperature for the key activities in legume-rhizobium systems. Activity Seed germination Effect of low Effect of high temperature range Optimal soil temperature (<15C) temperature (>35C)

20-30 C Delayed imbibition, Accelerated metabolism, poor viguor reduced viability Remarks / Citations (Hatfield and Prueger, 2015) and (Yeremko et al., 2025) Root elongation 20-28 C 70% reduction in

Tip damage, inhibited (de Moraes and Gusmao, soybean at 12 C elongation and branching 2021) and (T ripathi Sparse branching, Auxin imbalance, hormonal disruption reduced adventitious roots Reduced cell division, Increased respiration, (Tchapga et al., 2023)

poor vascular reduced carbon allocation and (Walne and Reddy, et al., 2024) Lateral root 22-30 C Formation Root biomass 19–30 C accumulation development Rhizobial 20-30 C colonization (Tripathi et al., 2024)

2022) Delayed Nod factor Membrane instability, (Liu et al., 2019) and synthesis, impaired reduced signaling (Mohammadi et al., 2012) infection threads Nodule initiation Species-specific Delayed primordia

Genetic stress, (Junior et al., 2005) and (15-25 C) formation, reduced nodulation failure (Hungria and Vargas, nodule number Nitrogenase 25-30 C activity Heat shock >40C 2000) 60% decline at 4C 40% reduction at

in B. japonicum nodules ~39C in chickpea and (Jain et al., 2014) Not induced Upregulated to protect (Yang et al., 2022) and nitrogenase and inhibit (Michiels et al., 1994) protein expression (Zhang et al., 2014)

thermal aggregation of MDH Cold-responsive <15C Gene expression Agronomic Upregulated (e.g., Suppressed GmFRI-1, CBFs) and (Thomashow, 2010) Buffers cold stress, Reduces evapotrans- (Lakhani and Bodar, Interventions

improves microbial piration, stabilizes 2025) and (Demo and (Mulching) activity root zone Asefa Bogale, 2024) Thermotolerant strains Cold-adapted strains (Asadi Rahmani et al., underperform underperform

2009) and (Alexandre Avoid early sowing Avoid peak in cold soils heat periods Microbial inoculant All ranges (Zhang et al., 2025) 20-30 C Selection and Oliveira, 2011) Sowing window Optimization Volume Issue

Region-specific (Zhang et al., 2019) 5 Thermal Sensitivity of Legume-rhizobium Interactions: Root Morphogenesis and Variability: A Review

CONCLUSION Soil temperature critically shapes root architecture and legume-rhizobium symbiosis, influencing water uptake, nutrient acquisition and nitrogen fixation. Extreme heat or cold impair root development and symbiotic efficiency. Integrating thermotolerant rhizobial strains, optimized inoculants, mulching and conservation tillage helps buffer temperature stress. Strategic sowing windows and rootzone management further enhance nodulation in rainfed systems. Molecular insights into heat shock proteins and cold-responsive genes offer new breeding targets for thermal resilience. Coupled with ICT-based advisories and region-specific agrometeorological data, these interventions can boost legume productivity and soil health. A systems approach, linking genetic, microbial and agronomic innovations is essential for sustaining biological nitrogen fixation and advancing climate-smart agriculture.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Fig 3: Graphical abstract of soil temperature and legumerhizobium symbiosis. like Jeevamrit and Bijamrut to enhance nutrient cycling and nitrogen fixation (Lakhani and Bodar, 2025). Mulching also suppresses weeds, reduces evapotranspiration and cold stress, making it especially valuable in dryland and semiarid regions (Demo and Asefa Bogale, 2024). Thermotolerant strains of Rhizobium, Azospirillum and phosphate-solubilizing bacteria improve nodulation and nutrient uptake. Inoculants applied with organic carriers and placed near the root zone, often alongside mulching enhance microbial efficacy (Abro et al., 2011). Regionspecific formulations are increasingly recommended to match local soils and cropping systems. Sowing window optimization-based on soil temperature thresholds improves germination and seedling vigour. Aligning sowing with seasonal rainfall and temperature patterns boosts yields (Zhang et al., 2019). Longterm Agrometeorological data and crop-weather calendars guide ideal sowing periods for rainfed crops. Together, these interventions form a low-cost, synergistic framework for climate-resilient agriculture across diverse agro-climatic zones. Integrated with conservation agriculture and ICT-based advisories, they strengthen soil health, microbial diversity and crop productivity under temperature stress. Way forward To enhance legume productivity and nitrogen fixation under variable soil temperatures, integrated agronomic management strategies are essential to improve resilience. Advanced inoculant technologies, including encapsulated and polymer-enriched formulations may strengthen the nodulation process. Molecular insights into heat shock proteins, cold-responsive genes and hormonal pathways provide breeding targets. Embedding these approaches in extension programs, policies and farmer training ensures scalable adoption across diverse agro-climatic zones. 6

The authors gratefully acknowledge the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment and the University Grants Commission (UGC), Government of India, for the student fellowship and sincerely thank the scientists of the DST– Centre of Excellence on Disaster and Climate Resilient Agriculture, Agro Climate Research Centre, TNAU, Coimbatore, for valuable support in collecting review materials. Disclaimers The views and conclusions expressed in this article are solely those o f the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of their affiliated institutions. The authors are responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the information provided, but do not accept any liability for any direct or indirect loss resulting from the use of this content. Informed consent No animal used during the research.

📖 中文全文 Chinese Full Text

中文

# 翻译

LR-5609 [1-10] 综述文章 豆类研究—国际期刊

## 豆科-根瘤菌互作的热敏感性:根系形态建成与变异性综述

M Panchulakshmi¹, Dheebakaran Ga¹, N.K. Sathyamoorthy¹, D. Jegadeeswari², B. Arthirani³, M. Dhasarathan¹, S. Mohan Kumar¹

10.18805/LR-5609

## 摘要

豆类作物对粮食和营养安全至关重要,因其高蛋白含量常被称为"穷人的肉类"。其在可持续农业中的核心地位源于生物固氮(BNF)——一种涉及根瘤菌的共生过程,该过程对土壤温度波动高度敏感。土壤温度调控根系构型(RSA)、微生物定殖和酶活性,是决定豆类生产力的关键因素。极端土壤温度损害根系活性、微生物共生和氮固定。本综述综合了来自分子生物学、微生物生态学和农艺措施等领域的91篇(共124篇)同行评审研究。文章考察了影响结瘤动力学、根系构型性状和共生基因表达的温度阈值,包括热激蛋白(HSPs)、冷响应基因(如GmFRI-1)和激素信号通路。根系构型性状如根系伸长、分枝、生物量和维管发育均对温度敏感,在20-30°C范围内表现最佳。低温胁迫延迟结瘤并降低固氮酶活性(4°C时降低约60%),而高温胁迫损伤根尖并减少固氮酶还原酶(约降低42%)。分子响应包括生长素运输紊乱和热激蛋白诱导。耐热根瘤菌菌株、结瘤因子(Nod因子)和接种策略有助于维持共生关系。覆盖、保护性耕作和适时播种等农艺措施可调节土壤热状况并增强微生物活性。通过整合遗传、微生物和农艺策略管理豆科-根瘤菌系统的热敏感性,对于气候适应性豆类栽培以及在可变土壤温度条件下维持生产力至关重要。

**关键词:** 豆科作物、管理、根瘤菌、根瘤、土壤温度、共生。

豆类作物在粮食和营养安全中发挥着关键作用,尤其对低收入和素食人群意义重大。因其蛋白质、必需氨基酸和价格可负担性,豆类被称为"穷人的肉类"。豆类富含铁、锌和叶酸等微量营养素,有助于均衡饮食并对抗隐性饥饿。从农学角度看,豆类通过生物固氮(BNF)维持农业系统,在此过程中共生根瘤菌将大气中的氮转化为植物可利用的形式,减少化肥依赖并提高土壤肥力(Wissal等,2020;Owaresat等,2023)。豆类在营养和农业生态韧性方面的双重作用使其成为气候智能型农业和包容性粮食系统的核心。

## 全球和区域豆类作物与粮食安全

豆类作物具有多样化的全球起源中心,反映了其跨大陆的古老驯化历史。鹰嘴豆和扁豆驯化于肥沃新月地带(Zohary等,2012)。豌豆起源于地中海盆地和中亚。大豆起源于中国东北部(Hymowitz和Shurtleff,2005)。菜豆在中美洲和南美洲安第斯地区有双重起源中心(Bellucci等,2013),而蚕豆起源于近东,尽管其野生祖本尚未确定(Caracuta等,2016)。花生原产于南美洲,特别是巴西和秘鲁(Krapovickas,2017)。豇豆起源于撒哈拉以南非洲,适应干旱气候和低投入系统(Boukar等,2019)。山黧豆以其耐旱性著称,原产于地中海和南亚热带地区(Gonçalves等,2024)。印度是多种热带豆类的主要起源中心,如木豆、黑绿豆、绿豆、硬壳豆、扁豆荚和蛾豆均原产于印度次大陆,长期以来支撑着雨养自给农业和蛋白质营养(Srivastava等,2025)。这些起源凸显了豆类在印度各农业气候区塑造韧性粮食系统中的生态和文化意义。

豆科作物应对全球粮食和营养安全挑战,尤其在蛋白质缺乏饮食地区具有重要意义(Salaria等,2022;Amel等,2018),其蛋白质含量丰富(20-35%)(Grdeñ和Jakubczyk,2023),还含有必需氨基酸、纤维、维生素和矿物质(Çakir等,2019)。豆类提供了一种营养均衡的动物蛋白替代品(Rajput等,2024),使其在印度素食人群中特别有价值,豆类是印度饮食的主粮。全球范围内,对植物基蛋白的需求不断上升,反映了健康和可持续性方面的关注(Aschemann-Witzel等,2021)。

扁豆、鹰嘴豆、绿豆和大豆等豆类因其营养和生态韧性被认定为"未来智慧食物"(Sharma等,2024)。在印度,豆类对蛋白质摄入贡献显著,并深深植根于农村传统粮食系统(Singh等,2017;Sonika等,2020)。除人类营养外,豆类还通过减少对资源密集型畜牧业的依赖来支持可持续饮食(Röös等,2020)。将豆类纳入种植系统可增强粮食系统的多样性和韧性,与联合国可持续发展目标(SDGs)一致,特别是SDG 2(零饥饿)和SDG 13(气候行动)(Unicef,2022)。尽管豆类有诸多益处,但其生产受到低产、生物和非生物胁迫以及有限政策支持的制约。育种、生物强化和增值加工是增强其在全球粮食和营养安全中作用的关键。

## 土壤温度与作物生产

土壤温度是调控农业中生物、化学和物理过程的基本环境变量。它直接影响种子萌发、根系发育、微生物活动、养分矿化和水分吸收,是作物生产力的关键决定因素(Hatfield和Prueger,2015)。热带和亚热带作物的最适土壤温度通常为20-30°C,因物种和生长阶段而异。季节性或气候引起的温度偏离可破坏酶活性和激素信号,损害种子吸胀、胚根伸出和根系伸长(Yanjun等,2005)。冷土延迟萌发并削弱幼苗活力,而过高的温度加速代谢但损害根系完整性和水分平衡。养分有效性和吸收也受到影响,冷土中磷的有效性因微生物活性受限而降低(Blackwell等,2010)。微生物过程如分解、硝化和共生对温度高度敏感,影响微生物量、多样性和养分循环。

覆盖、覆盖作物和残留物管理等保护措施有助于维持微生物健康和作物韧性的最适热状况(Lal,2020)。此外,土壤温度与水分动态相互作用,影响蒸腾作用、根系吸水能力和抗旱性。近期研究表明,土壤温度在调节酶活性、膜流动性和激素信号方面发挥作用,影响萌发、根系生长和生物质积累(Yeremko等,2025)。了解土壤温度动态对于优化豆类生产力、指导播种窗口、品种选择和气候适应性农业的接种策略至关重要。虽然温暖土壤可能延长温带生长季节,但在热带地区也会加剧热胁迫并破坏根系-微生物互作。深入理解这些动态对于设计适应性农艺措施、选择耐热品种以及在多变气候下优化播种时间至关重要。

## 土壤温度胁迫下的根系构型

根际对温度波动高度敏感,尤其在豆类中,根系-微生物互作驱动生产力。土壤温度塑造根系构型(RSA),影响根系伸长、分枝和生物量(Luo等,2020)。RSA调控水分和养分吸收、微生物定殖和胁迫抗性。30厘米垄顶的双层施肥通过缓冲土壤温度,以较浅角度、侧向增殖、直径增加和垂直扩展改善根系几何形态(Kang等,2025)。相反,较冷根区(7-13°C)限制根系生长并减小导管尺寸,损害矿物质吸收和转运(Miao等,2023)。

### 根系伸长

根系伸长对温度高度敏感,大豆根系伸长在30°C左右达到峰值,12°C时下降70%(de Moraes和Gusmao,2021)。接近零度的温度使小麦和玉米等谷物根系停止延伸(Morandage等,2021),而冷土降低春季谷物根系长度密度,限制土壤探索能力(Qin等,2018)。大多数豆类在20-28°C范围内伸长最佳;低于15°C时细胞分裂减缓,高于35°C时根尖受损,减少伸长和侧根形成。

### 侧根形成

适度温暖的土壤促进生长素介导的侧根发育,而过高的温度破坏激素信号,产生稀疏根系。Tripathi等(2024)报道,暴露于波动土壤温度的豆类表现出分枝模式改变和不定根密度降低,损害结瘤和固氮。

### 生物量积累

根系生物量在最适土壤温度和水分条件下达到峰值。豆类在较低温度(19-20°C)下表现出更高的根系生物量,这是由于保水性改善和热胁迫减少(Tchapga等,2023)。升高温度加速分解但通过增加呼吸和减少碳分配降低生物量。在玉米中,30/22°C和35/27°C条件下根系干重最高(Walne和Reddy,2022),而高于环境温度4-6°C的增温使细根退化并减少吸收根生物量(Parts等,2019)。在寒冷生态系统中,增温增加了根系、真菌和食真菌动物生物量,而细菌和古菌水平保持稳定(Salazar等,2020)。

## 根瘤菌功能的热敏感性

### 土壤温度胁迫下的根瘤菌活性与定殖

土壤温度是根瘤菌活性、定殖效率和豆科-根瘤菌共生的关键决定因素。根瘤菌在20-30°C范围内表现出最佳代谢活性和BNF(Bordeleau和Prévost,1994),低于15°C或高于35°C则损害细菌活力、信号交换和共生功能。低温减缓根瘤菌代谢,减少结瘤因子(Nod因子)合成并延迟定殖(Liu等,2019)。冷胁迫还改变根瘤菌和宿主根系中的基因表达,影响早期信号传导和结瘤启动。相反,升高温度可能促进根系生长但破坏根瘤膜完整性、酶稳定性和信号分子产生(Kumar等,2023;Caruso等,2014)。

土壤温度强烈影响根瘤菌运动性、趋化性和根毛附着,这是定殖的关键步骤。适度温暖促进这些过程并增加根瘤生物量,而超出最适范围(20-30°C)的温度延迟定殖(Zhang等,2020)。最适温度(20-30°C)有利于根瘤菌定殖、根瘤发育和固氮酶效率。相反,低于15°C或高于30°C的温度可阻碍结瘤并降低固氮速率(Aranjuelo等,2007;Mohammadi等,2012)。重要的是,根瘤菌菌株在耐热性方面存在差异,一些菌株在热胁迫下维持共生效率,使其选择对温暖气候下的豆类栽培至关重要(Asadi Rahmani等,2009;Alexandre和Oliveira,2011)。

### 根瘤菌接种剂配方与递送系统

温度胁迫下根瘤菌接种剂的效力取决于菌株选择和配方。以泥炭、褐煤或木炭为载体的接种剂有助于缓冲根瘤菌免受干燥和热波动影响,延长保质期和田间活力(Bashan等,2014)。富含保护性聚合物和渗透调节剂的液体接种剂增强耐热性和快速定殖,尤其适用于高温环境(Tittabutr等,2007)。海藻酸珠或生物炭基质中的包封创造保护性微环境,调节温度和水分胁迫(Schoebitz和López Belchí,2016)。将接种剂精准施用于根际附近,特别是在覆盖或保护性耕作系统中,可增强结瘤。将耐热菌株与优化配方和靶向递送相结合,可在气候变异下维持共生关系。

### 结瘤启动的分子机制

根瘤形成始于宿主根系与相容根瘤菌之间的分子对话。在根瘤内,根瘤菌分化为固氮类菌体(Bacteroides)(Ledermann等,2021),受时空调控的信号网络支持。根瘤创造微氧环境以促进养分交换和固氮酶活性。土壤温度影响根瘤发育和根瘤菌菌株竞争力,例如,B. diazoefficiens USDA 110/122在28/23°C表现最佳,而B. japonicum USDA 123偏好较冷条件(Shiro等,2016)。维持最适土壤温度并使用耐热菌株配合适当的土壤管理可提高共生效率和豆类生产力。

## 根瘤菌功能的热敏感性

### 土壤温度对结瘤的影响

根瘤菌与豆类形成共生关系,通过结瘤实现大气氮固定(Masson-Boivin和Sachs,2018;Raza等,2020)。该过程始于根系分泌的黄酮类化合物,吸引相容根瘤菌并诱导结瘤因子(Nod因子)合成(Abd-Alla等,2023)。这些信号被根表受体识别,触发根毛卷曲和侵染线形成(Krönauer和Radutoiu,2021;Ghantasala和Roy Choudhury,2022)。土壤温度对根瘤菌菌株竞争力和根瘤占据具有关键影响。例如,B. diazoefficiens USDA 110/122在28/23°C结瘤最佳,而B. japonicum USDA 123偏好较冷条件,凸显了温度特异性菌株选择的重要性(Shiro等,2016)。

### 温度对根瘤发育的影响

根瘤发育的最适根区温度因物种而异:热带豆类为25°C,豌豆为20°C,扁豆为15°C(Junior等,2005)。偏离最适温度延迟结瘤启动并降低根瘤大小、数量和生长速率。根瘤菌定殖也随温度变化,根际种群在20-30°C之间上升,而鹰嘴豆中内生运动在25°C达到峰值(Landa等,2004)。在20-30°C条件下,缓生根瘤菌(Bradyrhizobium)与巴西固氮螺菌(Azospirillum brasilense)共接种增强大豆结瘤,在76%土壤保水率和每株112个根瘤时效率达到峰值(Deak等,019)。相反,低温(15°C)降低三叶草生产力并延迟结瘤(Janczarek等,2024),而高温(>40°C)可导致结瘤失败和根瘤菌遗传胁迫(Hungria和Vargas,2000)。

### 热激蛋白在结瘤发育中的作用

在豆类中,热激蛋白(HSPs)对结瘤发育期间的共生关系至关重要,可防止蛋白质聚集并维持细胞稳态(Ogden等,2017;Flynn等,2024)。GmHSP17.9等小分子HSP在45°C下抑制苹果酸脱氢酶的热聚集,支持早期信号传导和分化(Yang等,2022)。HSPs还保护固氮酶免受热诱导变性和氧化胁迫,维持氮固定(Rajaram和Apte,2008)。耐热根瘤菌菌株如CIAT899在40-45°C下上调特异性HSPs(如21 kDa),增强耐热性(Michiels等,1994)。其胁迫诱导表达使HSPs成为耐热豆类育种的有价值生物标志物和育种目标,在气候胁迫下支持共生效率(Aranjuelo等,2015)。

### 冷响应基因及其对结瘤的影响

冷响应基因使豆类能够在低温胁迫下维持共生关系,其编码的蛋白如C-repeat结合因子(CBFs)、抗冻蛋白和渗透保护酶可维持细胞稳态(Thomashow,2010)。活性根瘤菌共生通过增强抗氧化防御和调节冷响应基因提高苜蓿的耐寒性(Liu等,2019)。冷胁迫破坏激素信号传导,细胞分裂素对结瘤因子转导和根瘤器官发生至关重要(Dolgikh等,2016),而低温抑制生长素转运蛋白(PIN1-PIN7),损害根系伸长和向重力性(Tiwari等,2023)。固氮酶活性对冷高度敏感,在4°C下24小时内慢生型大豆根瘤菌(Bradyrhizobium japonicum)根瘤中下降60%(Zhang等,2014)。然而,GmFRI-1等基因有助于在冷胁迫下维持结瘤,其过表达增强4°C下大豆根瘤形成,而RNAi沉默则抑制结瘤(Zhang等,2025)。

### 温度胁迫下的根瘤衰老

根瘤衰老是一个有序过程,涉及类菌体和大豆细胞的程序性死亡,导致固氮逐渐下降(Tsyganova等,2023)。温度强烈影响衰老过程:在28°C下,野生型SGE根瘤三天后从中心开始衰老,而突变系SGEFix"-3和SGEFix"-7在一天内即出现快速顶端和基部衰老(Serova等,2023a)。热诱导的衰老也受激素通路调控,GA失活(PsGA2ox1)、乙烯(PsACS2、PsACO1)、茉莉酸(PsLoxN1)和ABA合成基因(PsNCED2、PsAO3)上调,同时GA生物合成基因PsGA20ox1下调——共同促进根瘤老化(Serova等,2023b)。

## 土壤温度变异下的固氮动态

生物固氮(BNF)对土壤温度高度敏感,极端温度威胁共生效率和作物生产力(Flynn等,2024;Kajić等,2016)。保护性耕作通过改善保水性、调节温度和增加微生物量来增强结瘤和BNF(Torabian等,2019)。根区温度(RZT)至关重要:山黧豆在低于10°C时固氮停止,温带根瘤菌在25°C达到峰值,耐寒菌株在15°C达到峰值(Mahdavi等,2010)。这凸显了将根瘤菌热适应与当地土壤条件匹配的重要性。在北极土壤中,BNF在低于14°C且水分充足时达到峰值,表明耐寒固氮菌对增温的脆弱性(Rousk等,2018)。在温带地区,BNF速率随温度升高而上升,在中等水分条件下35°C时达到峰值(Li等,2018)。在鹰嘴豆中,固氮酶和硝酸还原酶活性在开花期达到峰值,但在约39°C时下降,固氮酶还原酶下降40.12%,固氮酶下降20.21%(Jain等,2014)。铵同化酶GS和GOGAT对热胁迫更为敏感(Hungria和Kaschuk,2014)。这些发现凸显了在气候胁迫下维持BNF的温度韧性共生系统的迫切需求。土壤温度与豆科-根瘤菌系统关键活动之间的互作总结于表1和图文摘要(图3)中。

## 土壤温度管理的农艺和微生物措施

土壤温度调控种子萌发、根系发育、微生物活动和养分循环,使其管理在气候变异下至关重要。用秸秆、落叶或绿肥覆盖可缓冲温度、保持水分并促进微生物健康。在印度自然农业中,覆盖与Jeevamrit和Bijamrut等投入物协同作用,增强养分循环和氮固定(Lakhani和Bodar,2025)。覆盖还抑制杂草、减少蒸腾和冷胁迫,在旱地和半干旱地区尤为有价值(Demo和Asefa Bogale,2024)。

根瘤菌、固氮螺菌和溶磷菌的耐热菌株可改善结瘤和养分吸收。接种剂与有机载体配合施用于根际附近,通常与覆盖结合使用,可增强微生物效力(Abro等,2011)。越来越推荐使用区域特异性配方以匹配当地土壤和种植系统。基于土壤温度阈值的播种窗口优化可改善萌发和幼苗活力。使播种与季节性降水和温度模式同步可提高产量(Zhang等,019)。长期农业气象数据和作物-天气日历为雨养作物指导理想播种期。

这些措施共同构成了一个低成本、协同的气候适应性农业框架,适用于不同农业气候区。与保护性耕作和基于ICT的咨询相结合,它们可在温度胁迫下增强土壤健康、微生物多样性和作物生产力。

## 展望

为提高可变土壤温度下的豆类生产力和固氮能力,需要综合农艺管理策略以增强韧性。先进接种技术,包括包封和富含聚合物的配方可增强结瘤过程。对热激蛋白、冷响应基因和激素通路的分子见解提供了育种目标。将这些方法嵌入推广项目、政策和农民培训中,可确保在不同农业气候区的大规模采用。

## 结论

土壤温度对根系构型和豆科-根瘤菌共生具有关键影响,涉及水分吸收、养分获取和氮固定。极端高温或低温损害根系发育和共生效率。整合耐热根瘤菌菌株、优化接种剂、覆盖和保护性耕作有助于缓冲温度胁迫。策略性播种窗口和根区管理进一步增强雨养系统的结瘤。对热激蛋白和冷响应基因的分子见解为热韧性提供了新的育种目标。结合基于ICT的咨询和区域特异性农业气象数据,这些措施可提高豆类生产力和土壤健康。将遗传、微生物和农艺创新联系起来的系统方法对于维持生物固氮和推进气候智能型农业至关重要。

## 致谢

作者感谢印度社会正义与赋权部和大学拨款委员会(UGC)提供的学生奖学金,并衷心感谢TNAU哥印拜陀农业气候研究中心DST-灾害与气候韧性农业卓越中心科学家在收集综述材料方面的宝贵支持。

## 免责声明

本文所表达的观点和结论仅代表作者本人,不一定代表其所属机构的观点。作者对所提供信息的准确性和完整性负责,但不承担因使用本内容而产生的任何直接或间接损失的责任。

## 知情同意

研究过程中未使用动物。